Insight & news /
The Milburn Review: the difficult politics begin now
There is no doubting the scale of Milburn’s ambition. His report proposes a fundamental shift from managing youth economic inactivity through the benefits system towards investing earlier in education, training, health and employment support.
The aim is to reduce the proportion of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET) from around 13% today to 5% by 2036. Milburn estimates that his proposals could help an additional 440,000 young people into employment, alongside 150,000 more young people participating in further education each year and an increase in annual apprenticeship starts for under-25s to around 270,000 by 2036/37.
But the political and practical challenges are considerable.
A different Prime Minister, a different political approach
There is an interesting irony at the heart of the Review. Milburn was appointed by Keir Starmer but is delivering his recommendations to Andy Burnham.
It is far from certain that Burnham would have commissioned such a sweeping review or appointed Milburn to lead it. Yet he now faces the challenge of responding to reforms that cut across almost every part of his domestic policy agenda.
To his credit, the political preparation has been a marked improvement on last year’s welfare reforms.
Rather than allowing the debate to become dominated by benefit reductions, Burnham and Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden have emphasised investment, support and opportunity. Milburn has also spent considerable time engaging Labour MPs and wider stakeholders.
The result is a more measured initial parliamentary response. But that should not be mistaken for unconditional support.
Concerns extend beyond those who opposed welfare reform last time. MPs across the parliamentary party will want answers about how the proposals work, what they cost and whether the promised opportunities will exist.
Those questions will become harder when ministers move from welcoming the ambition to introducing legislation.
The employer problem
Perhaps the biggest challenge is that the Government cannot deliver Milburn’s ambitions on its own.
There is a tendency to treat apprenticeships, training programmes and job guarantees as things government can simply decide to provide.
But an apprenticeship is a job. Someone has to create it, pay for it, train the individual and take responsibility for employing them.
And this is where the Government faces a fundamental contradiction.
Ministers want employers to create more opportunities for young people, including those who have been out of education or work. Yet other parts of the Government’s agenda risk making employers more cautious about taking that chance.
The Government’s employment rights reforms are particularly important. Stronger employment protections from day one and restrictions on zero-hours contracts will affect the calculations employers make when recruiting inexperienced workers.
That is not an argument against employment protections. But it raises questions about the additional obligations and risks of recruiting young people who may need more time and support to settle into work.
Add higher employer National Insurance costs and the ambition to equalise the National Living Wage for younger workers, and the cumulative effect on entry-level recruitment becomes difficult to ignore.
Milburn recognises the problem. His proposals include raising the employer National Insurance threshold for 21 to 24-year-olds from £5,000 to £10,000, alongside other hiring incentives.
But that change depends on the public finances allowing it. The costs and obligations facing employers are much more immediate.
Reconciling these priorities will be difficult. The employment rights reforms have strong support among senior Cabinet figures and much of the Parliamentary Labour Party, making significant changes politically challenging.
The danger is that the Government expands the supply of trained and work-ready young people without doing enough to create demand for their labour.
The cost of making a guarantee meaningful
The second challenge is financial.
Milburn estimates that his reforms will require annual government investment of around £5.8 billion by 2036/37, with costs eventually offset by lower welfare spending and increased tax revenues.
The long-term economic argument is compelling. The difficulty is that the costs come first.
Creating a genuine guarantee of employment, education or training will require substantial investment in services already under pressure, at a time when the Treasury faces competing demands across public services, defence and the wider spending programme.
Some recommendations give ministers flexibility over timing. But how much of the package can be delayed before the wider ambition becomes harder to deliver?
There is also a political risk in committing substantial public spending now in pursuit of savings that may not become visible for several years.
The real test comes next
The Review reaches across government in a way few policy interventions do. Delivering it will require coordinated decisions across welfare, education, business, health, housing, the Treasury and local government.
It will also require a different relationship between government and employers, with both sides taking greater responsibility for creating routes into work.
The Government has been more successful in preparing the political ground for Milburn than it was for last year’s welfare reforms. But the most difficult questions have not disappeared. They have simply been deferred.
For businesses, skills organisations, training providers and others involved in supporting young people, this creates an important opportunity to shape what comes next.
The debate now needs to move beyond whether Milburn’s ambitions are desirable to what will make them deliverable.
The Review may have had a relatively smooth launch. The politics of implementation will be much harder.